《斯坦福监狱实验》影评10篇
《斯坦福监狱实验》是一部由凯尔·帕特里克·奥瓦内兹执导,埃兹拉·米勒 / 李起弘 / 奥莉薇·瑟尔比主演的一部剧情 / 惊悚类型的电影,特精心从网络上整理的一些观众的影评,希望对大家能有帮助。
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(一):不能终止的斯坦福监狱试验
电影,都架不住反复琢磨。一般情况下,看完电影,还喜欢看看别人的影评,提高下认识。斯坦福监狱试验里,那个旁观的教授提问的那句,你这个实验的自变量是什么?影片一直没回答。而我却粗浅思考了些日子。
我想监狱实验的自变量应该是自然环境中人的天性吧,比如随和宽容善良等,影片开始时对应征者的询问表明,这些应试者都是正常人,都是我们身边的人。那么,实验时被赋予的权力和身份差异就应该是因变量了吧。试验结论应该是权力身份差异会扭曲人的天性,扼杀人性的善良宽容吧。
如果这个研究成果成立的话,那么社会,尤其朝鲜建国以来的历史,无不是在进行无休止的类似的监狱实验。领袖或者上级的一个随口的说法,就像实验设计者猜拳划分那样的随机赋权,就可以改变人的天性和预想的生活轨迹。这里的预想轨迹应该就是第一个进来的小伙子说的那句“有必要搞那么认真吗”所反映的心理吧。
领袖的一个想法,或者执行者按照自己的意愿所揣摩出的领袖想法,被占等级优势的执行者拿起鸡毛当令箭。影片最后,实验结束后,囚犯与狱警交流感想时说的那句话我很认同:“即使是职责所在,我觉得你也有点别出新意。如果是我,可能做不出来". ”别出新意“这个词,说出了弱势群体对秩序执行者行为的认识,可能是翻译的原因,我感觉内心里,囚犯想说的是”变态“,因权力而导致的变态。
这种因翻译而导致的模糊表达很适合我们当前的语境。很多领导,尤其是新上任的,想高升的,都在把上级赋予自己的维护社会正常运转的职责,过度夸张,运用到极致,美其名曰”制度创新“,”敢于负责“,实质上就是变态执行。很多领导者的行为,不是为了促进社会正常运转,各界融合,而是为了突出自身的权威和存在,吃拿卡要、设置障碍,制造轰动事件,挑拨激化社会矛盾。
很多囚犯或者平民眼里无关紧要或者正常的事务,监管者都希望以显示自己权威的方式运行, 试想我们的社会和人生,有多少仅仅是因为领袖一个随意的想法而改变。三反五反,一大二公,严打等,各种脱离常识、背离人性、脱离法治的社会运动显然就是监狱试验一次又一次的再现。 随手翻开新闻,甘肃某地为了拆迁,把农民还有几天就收获的麦子碾压在地里;某人仅仅因为围观或者一句顶嘴,网上几句评论,就会被拘留、被殴打、被伤害。
监狱试验评论中,引用最多的是大中学生的军训,简直就是我国对斯坦福监狱实验的原版照搬,教官和学员,都是试验环境中的随机赋权,都是1-2周的简短试验,然而,教官的各种变态作死,学生与教官间的服从与对抗,学生的心理变化过程,百度下这几年军训的负面新闻,多数与电影中的情节一模一样,少数甚至更为变态。
除了囚犯对因权力而导致的变态行为表达了不可接受外,影片结尾,警察扮演者对自我行为的辩解也很有代表性。都是上级安排的啦,也是我的职责啦,我是想考验一下你们的忍耐性啊。多少官员事后不都是采用了同样的借口吗?不知是导演抄袭了我们还是我们引进了西方价值。
尽管只是一个为期六天的实验,教授说终止就终止了,但我感觉带给实验人员的心灵触动和性格改变可能会影响终生。但假如社会就是这个样子,谁来终止它呢?我们什么时候才能够摆脱权力的扭曲,各层次参与者像一个正常人一样坐下来交流下对社会管理的看法呢?
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(二):Goddamn it
I know you're a good guy. Then why you hate me? Because I know what you can turn into. I prepared two years with the fear, when It's over, I still got fucking shocked with the endless frighten. Inhumanity can't happen any longer in the whole damn professors' world! Humanity can not be tested!
Fuck why should I watch this in the midnight?!Damn
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(三):人性本恶,不管你信不信,我是信了
在RPG游戏当中,你一定扮演过“主角”的角色,在建筑物中到处搜刮一些有用的道具。反思下自己在一些相对开放式的游戏,比如GTA,或者是神鬼寓言之类并没有给角色决定善恶而是用游戏的难度来界定善恶的游戏,在里面你还会遵守简单的伦理道德么?
答案肯定是否的,就算不为去了,为了探知这个游戏的下限,你也会违反这些伦理道德而去一试。为什么?因为这只是个游戏呀,是个有安全阀门的体验游戏,就算你在作恶的时候你也会明确的了解到,我手上玩的是个游戏,关上电脑我还是那个和姑娘说话会脸红的羞涩少年。
其实人们对道德下限的预测永远是不准的,或者说当你打算探底的时候却发现这个地方根本没有底线。现实是,如果你把一个人放到沉浸式体验的RPG如《西部世界》中描述的那样,你就不会不相信人性本恶这句话。当然你可以说再现实《西部世界》也只是一个连续剧,也只是一个关于人性的讨论,现实中没有这种作死的例子。
然而,美国人本着对心理学的研究就在这个边缘走了一会,用极为简陋的设备模仿了一个沉浸式RPG。
这就是《斯坦福监狱实验》
英文网站 - Home
1971年夏天,斯坦福大学的心理学教授菲利普津巴多在大学地下室搭建了一个模拟的监狱,政绩了24名禁止正常身体健康的志愿者,以每天15美元为报酬雇佣他们完成14天的实验。他们被随机分为囚犯和狱警两组,囚犯被“警车”逮捕并押送至监狱,搜身、扒光、清洗消毒、穿上囚服、去除姓名以号码代之。狱警则被发放了墨镜、警棍、制服等“装备”。
这个看起来像是过家家的实验并没有在第14天的时候结束,而是因为实验的结果已经远远超越了教授想得到的结果,在第六天的时候实验已经严重失控,不得不叫停。
关于斯坦福监狱实验的电影有三个
以斯坦福监狱实验和小说《黑盒子》改变的德国电影死亡实验 (豆瓣)
还原度最高的斯坦福监狱实验 (豆瓣)。
这三部作品,写实以《沉默的愤怒》为最,扩展性上以《死亡实验》为佳,但是要说起最给人心灵震撼发人思考的,还是15年的这部《斯坦福监狱实验》。作为一个平常人,在看了这个电影之后还是有思考和认识的。比如……
狱警拥有权力,而囚犯却只能服从,身为一个平常人怎么都会是想作为一个狱警存在吧,为什么各个应征者都倾向于做囚犯而并不是狱警这个让人费解,但是仔细想下就很清楚了,就是他们的身份和思考的角度。他们在介入这个实验的时候并不是作为实验者的身份进行思考,而是以一个平常人的伦理道德和价值观来选择,他们的答案是:"不想做坏人“或者直接点说是”不想成为坏人“,这就是他们在社会道德伦理规范约束下的一个倾向。所以所谓监狱,实际上就是和丛林法则相悖的一种生存手段,作为囚犯来既是“只要遵循规则就能有一日三餐晚上还有地方睡“,做囚犯不但避免了普世的道德风险,还能取得最进本的生存条件。
我相信他们进入角色前心里想的一定是“只要听话,在这个地方住两个星期就能拿着210美元走了”,然而事实并不是这样。
为什么人会成为更坏的人?
教授的课题,是环境对人类行为的影响。为了搭建这个环境,他找来假的警察、真的入狱流程,以及发放给狱警象征权力的墨镜和制服,以及暴力工具。我相信他一定知道实验的方向,但却没想到是以如此快的进程结束。环境难道对人的影响是如此的重要么?首先我认为,这场实验相对封闭的环境就关闭了安全词一说,甚至教授自己都陷身其中。就像SM开场的时候不设置安全词和安全动作,是极其危险的行为,这直接导致了实验者沉浸于角色的程度,对他们造成了永久的精神伤害。
不但是受虐者,施虐者也是如此,双方都在这个游戏中探知对方的底线,这个和恋爱很相像,恋爱常年不成功者往往都带着一种“他/她究竟能接受我多烂“的潜意识,结果口味越来越重,乙方无法承受,恋爱关系就结束。
这个其实和神鬼寓言的道理也是相同的,其实并不是在乎对方是善还是恶,而是能否达到的深度。在这方面,人类道德的准线远远没有野生动物的丛林法则来的清晰明显。于是当你把这个监狱准则抽离出来和人类现实社会做比较的时候,差距恐怕是你难以想象的。用我们中国人的话来讲就是:有人的地方就有江湖!
如何避免自己成为囚犯/狱警?
简单来讲要有清醒的自我意识,尽量不要玩这种角色扮演的游戏。如果要玩这种沉浸式的游戏也可以,但安全措施一定要做好。要培养自己的独立思考能力,要能抽离出来看自己的角色,无论是恋爱、生活还是学习、工作,都不能无休止的沉浸在其中,最好是有阶段性思考。不要让自己成为别人书中的角色,要学会像作者一样进行全局思考。
最后
这部电影严格意义上并不能说是恐怖片,甚至连惊悚片都说不上,当然前提是:
你了解你自己是什么样的人,会成为什么样的人
现在你知道从小玩的过家家有多么可怕了吧!
完
也可以关注我的微信公众号(undeadshawn)和知乎专栏(知乎专栏 undeadshawn)
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(四):Experiment?
首先最难以置信的是,整部电影是真实事件。我也很好奇做这个实验的心理学教授,到底是和这部电影的教授一样,只是想要看看后续发展是什么,还是纯粹的只想做实验。
整部电影的实验点,到底是想要表达权力的用途,还是想要表达没有法律的世界是怎么样的。
如果关于权力,我不得不说电影是成功的。不过短短六天,囚犯的世界只剩下了执行,而警官的世界充满了为所欲为。没有任何人喊停,也没有任何人阻止他们。就任由事情越发越大。
其实电影没有人为干涉吗?其实有的。逃跑,阻止逃跑,告诉他们可以随意用方法来惩治犯人。整部电影充满了实验者对被实验者的干涉,然而他们却还是认为自己没有干涉实验。早已经出现变量的实验注定了失败。
我还记得片尾说的。无论他们以后的人生是怎么样的,他们都无法忘记这一段经历。对于他们来言,这一段经历或多或少会给他们的心理以及身理上带来毁坏。
实验做到一定境界,请自我干涉的停止它。
不要用一个4厘米线长的酒精灯,用了,就是给自己的生命带来危害。
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(五):he Stanford Prison Experiment
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425037.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425039.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425041.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425043.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425045.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425047.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425049.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425051.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425053.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425055.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425057.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425059.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425061.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425063.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425065.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425067.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425069.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425071.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425073.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425075.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425077.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425079.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425081.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425083.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425085.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425087.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425089.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425091.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425093.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425095.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425097.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425099.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425101.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425103.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425105.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425107.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425109.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425111.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425113.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425115.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425117.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425119.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425121.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425123.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425125.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425127.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425129.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425131.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425133.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425135.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425137.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425139.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425141.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425143.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425145.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425147.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425149.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425151.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425153.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425155.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425157.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425159.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425161.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425163.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425165.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425167.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425169.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425171.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425173.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425175.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425177.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425179.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425181.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425183.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425185.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425187.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425189.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425191.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425193.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425195.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425197.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425199.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425201.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425203.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425205.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425207.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425209.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425211.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425213.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425215.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425217.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425219.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425221.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425223.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425225.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425227.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425229.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425231.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425233.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425235.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425237.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425239.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425241.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425243.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425245.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425247.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425249.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425251.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425253.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425255.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425257.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425259.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425261.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425263.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425265.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425267.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425269.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425271.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425273.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425275.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425277.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425279.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425281.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425283.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425285.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425287.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425289.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425291.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425293.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425295.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425297.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425299.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425301.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425303.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425305.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425307.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425309.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425311.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425313.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425315.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425317.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425319.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425321.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425323.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425325.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425327.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425329.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425331.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425333.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425335.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425337.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425339.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425341.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425343.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425345.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425347.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425349.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425351.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425353.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425355.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425357.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425359.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425361.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425363.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425365.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425367.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425369.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425371.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425373.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425375.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425377.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425379.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425381.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425383.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425385.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425387.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425389.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425391.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425393.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425395.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425397.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425399.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425401.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425403.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425405.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425407.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425409.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425411.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425413.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425415.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425417.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425419.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425421.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425423.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425425.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425427.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425429.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425431.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425433.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425435.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425437.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425439.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425441.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425443.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425445.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425447.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425449.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425451.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425453.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425455.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425457.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425459.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425461.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425463.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425465.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425467.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425469.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425471.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425473.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425475.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425477.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425479.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425481.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425483.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425485.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425487.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425489.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425491.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425493.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425495.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425497.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425499.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425501.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425503.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425505.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425507.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425509.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425511.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425513.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425515.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425517.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425519.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425521.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425523.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425525.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425527.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425529.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425531.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425533.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425535.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425537.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425539.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425541.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425543.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425545.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425547.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425549.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425551.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425553.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425555.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425557.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425559.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425561.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425563.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425565.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425567.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425569.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425571.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425573.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425575.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425577.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425579.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425581.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425583.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425585.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425587.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425589.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425591.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425593.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425595.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425597.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425599.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425601.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425603.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425605.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425607.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425609.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425611.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425613.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425615.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425617.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425619.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425621.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425623.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425625.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425627.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425629.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425631.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425633.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425635.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425637.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425639.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425641.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425643.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425645.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425647.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425649.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425651.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425653.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425655.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425657.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425659.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425661.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425663.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425665.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425667.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425669.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425671.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425673.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425675.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425677.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425679.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425681.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425683.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425685.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425687.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425689.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425691.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425693.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425695.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425697.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425699.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425701.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425703.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425705.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425707.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425709.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425711.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425713.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425715.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425717.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425719.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425721.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425723.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425725.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425727.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425729.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425731.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425733.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425735.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425737.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425739.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425741.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425743.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425745.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425747.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425749.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425751.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425753.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425755.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425757.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425759.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425761.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425763.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425765.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425767.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425769.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425771.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425773.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425775.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425777.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425779.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425781.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425783.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425785.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425787.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425789.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425791.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425793.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425795.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425797.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425799.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425801.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425803.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425805.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425807.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425809.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425811.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425813.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425815.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425817.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425819.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425821.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425823.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425825.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425827.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425829.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425831.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425833.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425835.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425837.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425839.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425841.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425843.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425845.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425847.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425849.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425851.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425853.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425855.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425857.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425859.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425861.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425863.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425865.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425867.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425869.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425871.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425873.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425875.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425877.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425879.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425881.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425883.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425885.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425887.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425889.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425891.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425893.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425895.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425897.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425899.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425901.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425903.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425905.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425907.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425909.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425911.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425913.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425915.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425917.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425919.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425921.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425923.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425925.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425927.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425929.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425931.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425933.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425935.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425937.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425939.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425941.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425943.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425945.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425947.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425949.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425951.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425953.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425955.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425957.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425959.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425961.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425963.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425965.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425967.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425969.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425971.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425973.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425975.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425977.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425979.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425981.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425983.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425985.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425987.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425989.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425991.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7425993.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425995.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425997.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7425999.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426001.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426003.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426005.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426007.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426009.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426011.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426013.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426015.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426017.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426019.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426021.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426023.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426025.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426027.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426029.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426031.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426033.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426035.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426037.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426039.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426041.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426043.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426045.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426047.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426049.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426051.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426053.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426055.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426057.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426059.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426061.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426063.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426065.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426067.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426069.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426071.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426073.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426075.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426077.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426079.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426081.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426083.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426085.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426087.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426089.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426091.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426093.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426095.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426097.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426099.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426101.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426103.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426105.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426107.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426109.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426111.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426113.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426115.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426117.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426119.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426121.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426123.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426125.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426127.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426129.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426131.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426133.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426135.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426137.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426139.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426141.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426143.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426145.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426147.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426149.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426151.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426153.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426155.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426157.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426159.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426161.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426163.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426165.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426167.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426169.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426171.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426173.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426175.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426177.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426179.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426181.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426183.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426185.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426187.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426189.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426191.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426193.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426195.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426197.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426199.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426201.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426203.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426205.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426207.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426209.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426211.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426213.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426215.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426217.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426219.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426221.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426223.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426225.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426227.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426229.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426231.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426233.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426235.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426237.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426239.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426241.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426243.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426245.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426247.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426249.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426251.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426253.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426255.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426257.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426259.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426261.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426263.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426265.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426267.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426269.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426271.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426273.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426275.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426277.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426279.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426281.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426283.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426285.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426287.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426289.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426291.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426293.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426295.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426297.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426299.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426301.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426303.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426305.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426307.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426309.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426311.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426313.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426315.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426317.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426319.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426321.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426323.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426325.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426327.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426329.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426331.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426333.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426335.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426337.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426339.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426341.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426343.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426345.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426347.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426349.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426351.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426353.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426355.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426357.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426359.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426361.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426363.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426365.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426367.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426369.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426371.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426373.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426375.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426377.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426379.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426381.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426383.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426385.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426387.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426389.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426391.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426393.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426395.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426397.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426399.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426401.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426403.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426405.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426407.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426409.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426411.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426413.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426415.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426417.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426419.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426421.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426423.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426425.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426427.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426429.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426431.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426433.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426435.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426437.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426439.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426441.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426443.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426445.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426447.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426449.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426451.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426453.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426455.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426457.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426459.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426461.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426463.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426465.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426467.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426469.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426471.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426473.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426475.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426477.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426479.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426481.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426483.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426485.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426487.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426489.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426491.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426493.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426495.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426497.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426499.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426501.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426503.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426505.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426507.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426509.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426511.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426513.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426515.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426517.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426519.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426521.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426523.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426525.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426527.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426529.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426531.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426533.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426535.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426537.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426539.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426541.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426543.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426545.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426547.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426549.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426551.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426553.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426555.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426557.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426559.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426561.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426563.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426565.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426567.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426569.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426571.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426573.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426575.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426577.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426579.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426581.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426583.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426585.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426587.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426589.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426591.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426593.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426595.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426597.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426599.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426601.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426603.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426605.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426607.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426609.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426611.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426613.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426615.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426617.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426619.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426621.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426623.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426625.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426627.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426629.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426631.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426633.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426635.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426637.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426639.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426641.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426643.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426645.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426647.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426649.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426651.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426653.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426655.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426657.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426659.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426661.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426663.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426665.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426667.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426669.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426671.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426673.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426675.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426677.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426679.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426681.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426683.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426685.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426687.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426689.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426691.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426693.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426695.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426697.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426699.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426701.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426703.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426705.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426707.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426709.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426711.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426713.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426715.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426717.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426719.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426721.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426723.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426725.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426727.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426729.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426731.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426733.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426735.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426737.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426739.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426741.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426743.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426745.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426747.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426749.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426751.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426753.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426755.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426757.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426759.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426761.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426763.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426765.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426767.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426769.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426771.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426773.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426775.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426777.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426779.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426781.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426783.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426785.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426787.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426789.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426791.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426793.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426795.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426797.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426799.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426801.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426803.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426805.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426807.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426809.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426811.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426813.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426815.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426817.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426819.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426821.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426823.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426825.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426827.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426829.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426831.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426833.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426835.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426837.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426839.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426841.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426843.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426845.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426847.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426849.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426851.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426853.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426855.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426857.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426859.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426861.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426863.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426865.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426867.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426869.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426871.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426873.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426875.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426877.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426879.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426881.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426883.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426885.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426887.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426889.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426891.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426893.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426895.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426897.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426899.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426901.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426903.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426905.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426907.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426909.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426911.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426913.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426915.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426917.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426919.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426921.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426923.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426925.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426927.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426929.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426931.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426933.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426935.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426937.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426939.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426941.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426943.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426945.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426947.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426949.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426951.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426953.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426955.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426957.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426959.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426961.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426963.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426965.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426967.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426969.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426971.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426973.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426975.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426977.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426979.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426981.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426983.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426985.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426987.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426989.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426991.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426993.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426995.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7426997.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7426999.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427001.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427003.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427005.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427007.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427009.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427011.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427013.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427015.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427017.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427019.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427021.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427023.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427025.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427027.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427029.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427031.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427033.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427035.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427037.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427039.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427041.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427043.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427045.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427047.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427049.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427051.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427053.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427055.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427057.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427059.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427061.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427063.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427065.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427067.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427069.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427071.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427073.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427075.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427077.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427079.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427081.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427083.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427085.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427087.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427089.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427091.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427093.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427095.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427097.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427099.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427101.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427103.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427105.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427107.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427109.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427111.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427113.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427115.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427117.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427119.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427121.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427123.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427125.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427127.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427129.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427131.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427133.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427135.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427137.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427139.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427141.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427143.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427145.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427147.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427149.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427151.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427153.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427155.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427157.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427159.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427161.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427163.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427165.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427167.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427169.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427171.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427173.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427175.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427177.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427179.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427181.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427183.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427185.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427187.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427189.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427191.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427193.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427195.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427197.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427199.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427201.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427203.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427205.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427207.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427209.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427211.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427213.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427215.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427217.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427219.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427221.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427223.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427225.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427227.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427229.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427231.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427233.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427235.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427237.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427239.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427241.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427243.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427245.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427247.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427249.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427251.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427253.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427255.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427257.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427259.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427261.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427263.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427265.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427267.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427269.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427271.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427273.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427275.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427277.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427279.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427281.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427283.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427285.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427287.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427289.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427291.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427293.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427295.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427297.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427299.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427301.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427303.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427305.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427307.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427309.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427311.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427313.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427315.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427317.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427319.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427321.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427323.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427325.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427327.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427329.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427331.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427333.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427335.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427337.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427339.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427341.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427343.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427345.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427347.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427349.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427351.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427353.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427355.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427357.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427359.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427361.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427363.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427365.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427367.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427369.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427371.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427373.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427375.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427377.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427379.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427381.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427383.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427385.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427387.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427389.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427391.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427393.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427395.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427397.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427399.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427401.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427403.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427405.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427407.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427409.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427411.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427413.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427415.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427417.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427419.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427421.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427423.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427425.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427427.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427429.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427431.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427433.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427435.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427437.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427439.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427441.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427443.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427445.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427447.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427449.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427451.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427453.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427455.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427457.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427459.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427461.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427463.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427465.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427467.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427469.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427471.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427473.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427475.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427477.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427479.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427481.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427483.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427485.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427487.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427489.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427491.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427493.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427495.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427497.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427499.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427501.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427503.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427505.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427507.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427509.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427511.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427513.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427515.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427517.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427519.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427521.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427523.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427525.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427527.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427529.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427531.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427533.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427535.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427537.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427539.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427541.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427543.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427545.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427547.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427549.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427551.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427553.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427555.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427557.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427559.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427561.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427563.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427565.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427567.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427569.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427571.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427573.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427575.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427577.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427579.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427581.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427583.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427585.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427587.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427589.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427591.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427593.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427595.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427597.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427599.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427601.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427603.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427605.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427607.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427609.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427611.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427613.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427615.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427617.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427619.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427621.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427623.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427625.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427627.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427629.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427631.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427633.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427635.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427637.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427639.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427641.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427643.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427645.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427647.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427649.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427651.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427653.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427655.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427657.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427659.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427661.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427663.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427665.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427667.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427669.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427671.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427673.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427675.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427677.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427679.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427681.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427683.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427685.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427687.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427689.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427691.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427693.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427695.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427697.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427699.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427701.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427703.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427705.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427707.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427709.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427711.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427713.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427715.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427717.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427719.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427721.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427723.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427725.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427727.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427729.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427731.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427733.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427735.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427737.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427739.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427741.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427743.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427745.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427747.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427749.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427751.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427753.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427755.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427757.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427759.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427761.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427763.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427765.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427767.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427769.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427771.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427773.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427775.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427777.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427779.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427781.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427783.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427785.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427787.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427789.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427791.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427793.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427795.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427797.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427799.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427801.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427803.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427805.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427807.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427809.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427811.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427813.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427815.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427817.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427819.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427821.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427823.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427825.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427827.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427829.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427831.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427833.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427835.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427837.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427839.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427841.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427843.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427845.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427847.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427849.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427851.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427853.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427855.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427857.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427859.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427861.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427863.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427865.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427867.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427869.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427871.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427873.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427875.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427877.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427879.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427881.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427883.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427885.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427887.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427889.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427891.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427893.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427895.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427897.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427899.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427901.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427903.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427905.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427907.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427909.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427911.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427913.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427915.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427917.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427919.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427921.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427923.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427925.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427927.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427929.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427931.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427933.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427935.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427937.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427939.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427941.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427943.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427945.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427947.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427949.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427951.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427953.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427955.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427957.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427959.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427961.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427963.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427965.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427967.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427969.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427971.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427973.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427975.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427977.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427979.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427981.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427983.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427985.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427987.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427989.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427991.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427993.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427995.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7427997.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7427999.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428001.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428003.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428005.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428007.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428009.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428011.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428013.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428015.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428017.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428019.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428021.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428023.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428025.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428027.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428029.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428031.html
k.qiyue.com/ssz/20151210/7428033.html
k.qiyue.com/sss/20151210/7428035.html
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(六):角色扮演的人性实验到底多有情趣?
文/Ri_Makoto 「PLEASE DO NOT USE ANY OF MY PERSONAL ARTICLES WITHOUT MY PERMISSION. THANKS.」
社会上常有许多事发生在当下,让人不由得产生出一种强烈的阶级观念,甚至时常会抱怨自出生起,为何就有人身处平民窟,而有人凭什么就含着金汤匙。当然,你也可以成为中层阶级中的平庸一族,一如往常起床、上班、工作到下班,活得像个事不关己高高挂起的“平凡人”。此时,远方的那些由阶级制造的伤害、残酷与血腥,可能只是书本上的一页描写,或是银幕上的一个片段,而不完全存在于我们所活的世界。但还好,我们还有那些渴望挖掘根基于现实人性的心理学家们,他们模拟环境,让那些所谓的道德原则变得不那么经得起推敲,甚至演变成一场游戏、一场恶作剧。而针对这种“可能”,电影《斯坦福监狱实验》就是最好的证明。
Oscar Wilde曾说:“最卑劣的行为就像是有毒的杂草一般繁茂地生长在监狱的空气里。”应了这句“至理名言”,1971年的心理学导师们开始研究起人性的永恒话题——是什么让一个人变得邪恶?一个好人也可以犯下罪行?又是什么推使着人们越过那条界限?有没有一个临界点,当人类跨过去之后,就会释放出邪恶?又或者说是否是因为彼时的处境决定了他们日后的行为?
带着种种问号,“斯坦福监狱实验(Stanford Prison Experiment)”来势汹汹地开始了,以24位大学生作为研究对象,随机分配为囚犯和狱警。囚犯要穿上女性连身裙和丝袜帽,以此来“抹去他们的性别和个性”,由一个“人”降级为一个“数字”,并在脚踝处套上铁链,以便随时提醒囚犯的低贱身份;而狱警这边装备齐全——包括木质警棍、军绿色制服,以及防止眼神交流的“墨镜”。
实验前,工作人员(包括实验策划者Zimbardo)就警告狱警不能以暴力伤害囚犯。但试验的录影中,你却看到Zimbardo对狱警说:“你们可以武断行事,囚犯的生活完全由我们控制。在这个实验中,你、我、他们都没有任何隐私。我们要用各种方式剥夺他们的个性,让自身拥有绝对的权利。”带着这种“反人道”的大前提,那些被选择扮演囚犯的实验者各自在他们的家中被“逮捕”,并以各种罪名起诉。当地的警察局协助实验,将他们运送到模拟监狱中,按照规定的流程脱衣搜身、清洁私处、去虱子,并赋予他们一套“意义非凡”的囚服装。
实验的第一天,还算平安无事,各种人带着每天来赚15刀美金的态度笑嘻嘻的度过了24小时。但,第二天在斯坦福大学的某栋建筑物的地下室里就发生了骚乱。就这么的,“预想”中的实验终于开始了!囚犯对非法监禁做出了反抗,狱警们残忍地采取了回击,把囚犯的衣服扒光、搬走了床,并强行拉出一些“极端分子”去小黑屋关禁闭。
最闹心的是,随着实验的进行,狱警们渐渐从抵抗变成了骚扰,直至施暴。导火索是一个谣言开始传播,说是一个囚犯要求退出实验,将会导致其他囚犯同样被释放。狱警只好将囚犯转移到另一个监狱,并把愤怒发泄在其他囚犯身上。好比,囚犯被要求快速的报数,这种做法可以在概念上加强他们囚犯身份的思想,变得更为“奴性”。之后,狱警就开始体罚,不允许囚犯上厕所,惩罚囚犯在冰冷的水泥地上睡觉;更甚,狱警将侮辱最大化,逼迫囚犯裸体,并以“Gay”,“bastard”等某些敏感词汇来进行语言暴力。
最为讽刺的是,第一次“反抗”无果之后,囚犯们开始无条件地服从狱警,更是硬生生地吞下了假释申请被拒的哑巴亏,不吭声地继续这场有趣的“游戏”。显然,这些扮演囚犯的人已经完全进入了角色之中,即便没有了报酬,他们骨子里潜藏的“奴性”让他们不由自主的留了下来。同样的情况也发生在了狱警身上,他们乐此不疲地辱骂虐待着囚犯;甚至,连左翼反战的Zimbardo也承认自己沉浸在了“监狱主管”的角色中,还装模做事地弄齐了假释委员会,不顾一切地阻止扮演囚犯的学生们中止实验。
当你以为本次实验只有一个对立面(狱警和囚犯)的时候,编剧Tim Talbott却来了个大反转——416,一个新来的囚犯。当他对其他囚犯的待遇忿忿不平时,狱警辱骂了他,他以绝食作为回应,拒绝吃掉他的香肠。看守面对样的“硬骨头”选择关进囚禁室的橱柜里,并带上其他囚犯一同惩罚,宣称只有囚犯放弃掉他们的毛毯,裸睡在穿床垫上,才可以解救出416。结果是,囚犯眼中,曾经的忿忿不平变成了多管闲事,除了其中一个人,其他人都拒绝这么做。对,416就这么被孤立了!
当事者迷,旁观者清。实验组之外的组织者们也全神贯注于新角色中,整日对着监控器忙于对付管理“监狱”时遇到的危机,而忘记了他们发起实验的初衷到底是什么。直到Christina Maslach(Zimbardo的女友)的干预之后,预计进行14天的实验,只维持了6天。在两者发生争执的对话中,Maslach一句“They are just boys”,Zimbardo才如梦初醒,怀疑起这场实验的道德性问题。
尽管实验提前宣布结束,但囚犯们在某种程度上依旧出现了情绪崩溃、神经质的征兆,从心理学的某种角度上来解释,他们不知不觉中早就承担了自己被指派的社会角色。这其中包括了接受与这些角色相关的隐含社会准则:狱警应该变得独裁,应该虐待囚犯,而囚犯则需要卑躬屈膝地忍受上层阶级给予的惩罚。
这个实验不可避免地引来了违背道德的探讨,包括样本过小、缺乏生态有效性等方面的批评。尽管如此,我们仍然难以否认,这个实验提供了对于人类行为的重要洞察,即在特定的一个合法的意识形态、社会体制支援下,人们的易感性和服从性都是“自备的”。这项实验也被用来描述认知失调理论的权威力量,更能够反映当下监狱里的“真实”情况。正如纽约最大的拘留所“Rikers Island”的狱警长所说——他早就习惯了对收容者的施暴程度,反正这是工作的一部分,免疫在所难免。
想想真是可怕,可能那些平日里不起眼的普通人中,都能够轻而易举地变成撒旦的奴隶,只要你拥有一点点“权利”。跃过那条界限,挥着“手臂的延伸”,在穿上制服的那一刻起,在制度里,眼前这些“好人”把灵魂中的另一个“我”无限延伸,延伸到忘记了本该拥有的身份、人性,还有道德。
如今,这项研究早就成为一种流行文化,并成就了不少电影作品,如《The Experiment》、《Die Welle》以及《Das Experiment》。追溯起来,谁曾想这项实验起初是为了研究二战时纳粹屠杀犹太人时,为什么那些协助者会允许这么可怕的事情发生,而当实验结果公布的当下则引起了相当大的反应——原来我们大多数人都会照着这样的权威指示去做,即便对方苦苦哀求,我们还是会含着泪水与内疚把残忍转换到最大,直至对方发不出声音为止。
最后,不得不像大家汇报这项实验的另一发现:三分之一的狱警在实验结束后都被戴上“真正”虐待狂倾向的帽子,而囚犯性格中的奴性也是我们不得不重新审视自我的一个导火索。
o,作为观众,如果轮到你来挑战这项实验,你又会期待哪重身份的演绎呢?控制或者被控制?在军队这种集权主义的小社会中,为了稳定军心,创造有效率的集中力量,来消灭“敌人”,你是否会变得极端狂热、排他,甚至热衷上互相监视告密,争相向上层阶级报告好友的诋毁和背叛呢?嘿,换一种阿Q精神来看,在这个还算太平的世界里,我们可能经历不到战争的消磨殆尽;但,眼前这起不算成功的实验,让我们深觉落寞、绝望、失却的哀伤情绪在某些时候真的会让人做出一些意想不到的疯狂事。无论是伤害他人,亦或是被他人伤害。
最后,用一句纳粹军官的话来结束我们的“意想不到”——“也许你觉得比我高尚。但,你错了,你只是比我幸运。因为,我们都是人。”
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(七):人性到底有多恶劣?!
起初看到这个电影的名字,以为只是一个实验,没什么大不了。看到开头,还在想,如果我是其中一员,会选择当囚犯还是狱警。看到那么多人选择当囚犯觉得很奇怪,我觉得选择狱警更有意思。可是实验一开始,我就发现根本不是那么回事,无论是囚犯还是狱警在这里都扭曲了人格。从第一天进监狱恐怖的折磨就开始了,连我这个看电影的人都感到十分憋屈。他们又不是真正的警察,有什么理由那样欺辱一个从未犯过罪的人?难道他们忘了这只是个实验?扒衣服、冲水、换囚服、吃硬面包,第一天就这样难捱,第二天,狱警变本加厉,本来是大学生的他们在此刻尽显人性之恶,规定“囚犯”必须吃饭剩饭,让他们不停报号码,甚至体罚,连睡觉都无法安稳。而“囚犯”却在顺从,狱警的权利不断变大,囚犯成了真正的犯人,而躲在摄像头后面的那些看似善良的面孔却异常冷漠,他们眼睁睁看着“囚犯”被打,似乎已经忘记了他们是根本没有犯过罪的大学生。时间过得异常缓慢,15天好似15年那么长,让看得人也深感压抑,我几次想冲进屏幕暴打狱警,人怎么可以这么残忍?!折磨还在继续,我渴望有人不再逆来顺受,终于,第三天的时候一个脾气暴躁的“囚犯”反抗了,看着他的歇斯底里,我感到酣畅淋漓,对,就要这样,凭什么把无罪的我关在这暗无天日的地方?还要日日折磨?我要出去!他出去了,仿佛一点希望显现。然而,监狱实验还在继续,剩下的人早已没了反抗的勇气,因为狱警说之前那个人因为不听话被关到别处去了,只有少数人知道他其实出去了。白色恐怖在蔓延,惨无人道的折磨在继续,似乎除了听从别无他法,教授不让任何人出去,他成了至高无上的幕后操手,这里成了真正的监狱,囚犯真的“犯罪”了,所以他们受到非人的对待,狱警变得疯狂,囚犯变得没有自己,这就是人性,当人们在拥有权力时会表现出恶,当人们身处卑微时表现出顺从,每个人都在这场试验中变了,变得不是自己了,仿佛一场噩梦。幸好,教授最后停止了实验,他总算悔悟,否则,“囚犯”和“狱警”只怕都会疯掉!!!
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(八):人性之恶
早就听说了路西法效应,今天通过电影,确实受到了震撼。这部电影循序渐进,跟着作者一步一步地观察实验的继续,甚至让观众有一种参与到实验中的感觉。给五颗星的原因是电影给我展示了人性之恶以及权力的威力。
之前便听说了很多虐囚事件,刚开始不理解这些,觉得狱卒人员太过残忍,不人道,稍微有点人性的人是不会这样做的。但是这个实验给出了答案,况且这只是个实验,仅仅持续了六天,就产生了这样的效果,并且实验开始之前,这些人是知道自己只是饰演各自的角色,并且可以获得报酬,但是实验到了最后每个人都置身于设置的监狱中,它成了一个真实的监狱,每个人都成为了真实的角色,而且无法自拔。可想而知那些传出丑闻监狱是多么的可怕。
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(九):感想
斯坦福监狱实验可怕在哪?在其某种程度上与现实生活的类似。而这种类似的根源在哪?在人心底的懦弱和顺从,自私和疯狂,冷漠和贪婪。我是善良的,相信有很多人也是善良的,但是直到看完这部电影我才清醒的意识到,处理某些事情时我的表现不是善良,而是懦弱!生活在这个存在诸多扭曲的社会,我们大多数人都只能跟着规则走,但是我们是不是只顾着走连自己做人的尊严都丢掉了?这部电影让我不寒而栗,它提醒了我,不要给自己设立斯坦福监狱,就算监狱是存在的,我不屑于做狱警更不要当囚犯。我会时刻提醒自己,永远不要把别人看得比自己高一等,永远不要在任何人面前降低自己的身份,永远不要输给自己性格中软弱的部分,永远不要顺从别人丢了自己,永远不要忘记是自己掌握着自己的行动力!
《斯坦福监狱实验》影评(十):人,亦正亦邪
去年阅讨课,读过一本名为Better Angel of Our Nature的书,里面,就有提到斯坦福监狱实验。
记不得书的具体内容了,只记得那是一本很难懂的书。毕竟要求读英文原版,而且里面不光有很多历史学方面的知识,还有大量心理学社会学和医学方面的背景知识。
我对心理学还是很感兴趣的,于是当时仔细看了书中关于斯坦福监狱实验的描述,以及实验背后的路西法效应。
后来,看了这部影片,内心居然毫无波澜,或许是因为,那些情节是在我意料之中的吧。
虽说内心毫无波澜,可是我对影片的印象还是很深刻的。
“我可以是个好人,也可以是个十足的恶棍,这,都取决于你。”
“我知道你是个好人,可我还是恨你,因为我知道你可以变得多坏。”
嗯,路西法效应。
这应该是圣经里的人物设定吧,那个堕落的天使路西法,就是后来的魔鬼撒旦。(难以确定是不是这个出处,毕竟我对英国文学还有圣经文学什么的不感冒。)
人,亦正亦邪,如此复杂。
没毛病。
后记:
其实我看了几篇影评,扯到滥用权力还有环境影响什么的。
如果是学术研究,我一定会指出来这些解读有些 go beyond the reasonable answer.
但是影评嘛,无所谓。我也该改一改吹毛求疵的毛病。
还有,毕竟,这世界绝大部分人并不拥有严密的逻辑。对此我无需较真。
其实我的第一反应也是,这影片会不会是想说,人在不同的环境下会被同化,根据所处环境做出相应的反应,像角色扮演一样。
但好像也不是。
难道所有狱警在面对囚犯时都会毫无理由变本加厉地凌辱囚犯吗?
难以明确,但感觉像是个伪命题。
所以我最初的设想被推翻。
再说滥用权力,也不是每一个拥有权力的人都会滥用职权啊。
所以归根结底还是想说人性吧。
应该是这样的吧。